From the XD38 web page "...over the long run they will not allow themselves to be disempowered by a substance (or an activity). The high self-preservation instinct kicks in. I need to discuss this self-preservation instinct at greater length, because it isn't what you think of when you think of an xd38, and it certainly isn't selfishness. I'd call it a logical consequence of accurate thinking. Also, what counts as self-preservation might differ markedly from the usual definition. CC, 5-25-2002]"
This explains how suicide can be an act of self-preservation. Not feeling able to find a place in the world, but at the same time being unwilling to lose my identity or betray my own ideals, can seem like a perpetual state of torture. Death is a better choice than losing my "self." The mass of the world seems overpowering at times.
Knowing our identity is a double-edged sword because we also can clearly see the heritage of pain as well as joy. This is fascinating to me. Thanks for letting me share it openly.
I think Wordsworth's Ode on Intimations of Immortality gives great insight on this idea. It is beautiful to watch his pain, rooted in "growing-up," turn to a jubilant awareness of the truths of existence and transcendence of form. Our hearts may attend the festivals of every spring, regardless of our age. I hope to see you there.
This explains how suicide can be an act of self-preservation. Not feeling able to find a place in the world, but at the same time being unwilling to lose my identity or betray my own ideals, can seem like a perpetual state of torture. Death is a better choice than losing my "self." The mass of the world seems overpowering at times.
Knowing our identity is a double-edged sword because we also can clearly see the heritage of pain as well as joy. This is fascinating to me. Thanks for letting me share it openly.
I think Wordsworth's Ode on Intimations of Immortality gives great insight on this idea. It is beautiful to watch his pain, rooted in "growing-up," turn to a jubilant awareness of the truths of existence and transcendence of form. Our hearts may attend the festivals of every spring, regardless of our age. I hope to see you there.
-
Unsu...
Re: Self-preservation
Tue, June 1, 2004 - 10:22 AMI don't overly-moralize suicide like people can be prone to do, however I feel sorry for people who have taken their own lives- not because they aren't alive anymore or whatever, but because they took themselves so seriously that they had to take such an action.
I don't disagree, it could have been self-preservation, the choice to commit suicide, but regardless...I just feel like those people weren't let in on the joke that is life, you know? Like what could be SOOOOOOOOOOO serious?! Money? Relationships? Blah, i dunno. Feel free to flame... -
-
Re: Self-preservation
Tue, June 1, 2004 - 1:05 PMyou're not wrong, namaste :)
I may not have been clear. I believe that people can subscribe to the illusion that suicide is an act of self-preservation. Reality is in the mind whether we want to believe it or not, so i like to discuss perception and illusion as bearing as much weight to sway an individual as concrete and familiar things. sometimes, i'm not careful in how i express myself. sorry 'bout that.
While suicide can be perceived as an act of self-preservation, especially by an XD38, I don't believe it is the healthy choice, obviously. :) Anyone who is contemplating suicide is already in a dysfunctional situation, so rational thought just isn't going to cut it at that point. I believe.
For intelligent, generally healthy, and mature people, depression and suicide make no sense. it's more like a trend than an event, and the cure is as mysterious as the illness itself. I wish telling myself that life is a joke would have snapped me out of it. :) I tried a lot of that. hehehe That's what made the experience so damn horrible. Nothing worked.
In one of my worst moments, i sat on the edge of my bed, in the dark, and felt panic because I couldn't tell if i was dead already and in "hell." That was due, i believe,to years of loneliness, exhaustion, and isolation. My pain has never been caused by one thing. As a generally positive person, my feelings of hopelessness made no sense to me which further sent me plummeting into the depths of despair. Being depressed is a living nightmare, but you can't wake up by telling yourself it's only a dream. Problems with money and relationships were child's play. LOL Materialism isn't really an issue for me, and I wasn't going hungry. Maybe that would have distracted me.
In my case, i think the despair came from incessantly deferred hopes and a negative atmosphere for too many years, as well as other stuff. I won't go into those details here, but most people consider suicide as the last option and feel they've exhausted other options. in most, if not all cases i've ever heard of, the idea that there are no other options is an illusion. but, when you question your own judgement and can't trust yourself, how can you help yourself? All i thought about, in those worst moments, was how I couldn't bear pain anymore. How i didn't want to hurt my family anymore because they were tired, and i was making them sad. sounds cheesy, but it's truly what i believed. i was doing all of us a favor. sure, it would hurt like ripping off a band aid, but, in a sense, i thought i was betraying myself to go on living just so they wouldn't feel the pain of my death. I was feeling immeasurable and ineffable pain and believed ending my experience called "life" would also hurt everyone less in the long run. The average pain would be less. sounds silly to me now. it makes little sense, but nightmares are surreal and make lots of sense when you're dreaming and none after you wake. you still have hope, though, if you can ask yourself if you're dreaming. i thought suicide was a perfectly logical and compassionate act, for me and everyone else. Luckily, i had enough self-doubt to make me question the act. in this case, self-doubt worked to save my life. the XD38 article helped me understand why i felt those things.. that suicide was saving my life. I wouldn't do it now, but i better understand how i subscribed to the illusion.
Logically, i could tell myself that I had choices, but because of the incapacitating nature of depression, I had no strength to act upon them. It's a real sickness. Horrible. It takes a miracle to survive it. Imagine a person who is bedridden due to illness. Depression to the point of suicide is no different. It's often metaphysical, though, which is why it's so hard to understand. We can trick the body and the mind, but it's harder to heal a broken spirit.
I never want to go back there. it's a dark hallway. a bottomless pit. a suffocating quagmire. thought didn't take me there, and thought couldn't help me out. I guess it does depend on why a person feels they have no more options. Every case is different.
seems like you're in no danger, namaste :) that's goooood.
I love Wordsworth because he managed to break through his painful illusions in spite of his pain. His new illusion is much nicer. :) oh lordy.
cheers!
-
Re: Self-preservation
Tue, June 1, 2004 - 1:08 PMI can see in a way how it could be looked at as "taking themselves so seriously", but that doesn't feel right to me. The people that live with the most pain in life usually have the most developed senses of humor out of necessity.
It's obvious that you havn't been there; keep it up. A life lived without being confronted by these issues is a *good* life :) -
-
Re: Self-preservation
Wed, December 8, 2004 - 8:50 AM>> A life lived without being confronted by these issues is a *good* life :)<<
Well said. If NO ONE had to confront these issues, the world and life would be much better.
I don't talk about it much, but the decision to take your own life is a very complex and personal one, and almost never does the person really understand the ramifications and impacts he/she will have on those who survive. I say this as someone who has had people close to him take their own lives, and as someone who has seen the world from the other side. Literally.
(now if that ain't an introduction to a tribe that will convince people to run like hell, I dunno what is).
By the way, I'm Chris, I'm NOT a psychopath, sociaopath, or even a forrestpath :-). -
-
Unsu...
Re: Self-preservation
Wed, December 8, 2004 - 9:40 AMi never knew anyone other than myself and brother that tried it.
(his attempt was 14 tylenol) i never told him i did. i took a whole bottle of asprin and wine.
what brought me to that point was this.
life is never easy for anyone....thats a given.but the ones that "live through this" are the ones that had something there to lean on. fam,god, chocolate..whatever.
i was living 3000 miles from anyone i knew.
my boyfriend...anything and everything you can think negative about a mate he was (or became)
had no money, no job, didnt talk to anyone in my family unless i was screaming at them for something they did to me or said to me. ( ex:my own father ripped me on an auto sale which was going to be my moving money to the 3000 miles away.)
basically i felt myself becoming bitter and lost and hateful. just like all of them. and they disgusted me. i just couldnt handle the pain people inflicted on me anymore. especially without any support from anywhere. i had lost faith in everything and everyone. all had changed from what i knew into some sort of bad directionless acid trip. i couldnt even muster up the care to respond when my boyfriend tried to talk to me that night. but i didnt hate him that night. i was so calm. its the wierdest calm i have ever felt. i knew that i never wanted to act like them. i didnt like them at all. and if you dont have love and family...what else is there. sitting in a dark room eating beans out of a can?
i would rather die at my own hands quickly than at the edged tounge of enemies slowly. i could of gave a flying fuck about how anyone else felt about what i did. they didnt care when i was alive so just because im dead they will...no.
i would of enjoyed that if they did anyway.(were being eaten by the guilt)
but i am glad i did what i did. being almost dead for three days really lifts the spirits. i never felt so revived. it was really really wierd. and plus i can catch people when they lie about trying it with pain killers....i hate when people lie about it. like it makes them interesting or cool. -
-
Re: Self-preservation
Wed, December 8, 2004 - 11:00 PMviolet, you've been through a lot, and you're in good company.
being alone is the worst torture for me. really. i find almost all meaning in communing with other living creatures, be they wild or domestic. with such a shortage of nature in the world today, safe nature, where we can walk without fearing a stray bullet, life becomes such a trial at times.
pets help me. i love the scene from Cable Guy, Jim Carrey's kareoke. "Don't you want somebody to love? Don't you need somebody to love?" .... yeah, i do (strange mixture of the sad and humerous, but it works for me)
flowers, birds, trees, people, whatever will share the air with me in safety.
safety and companionship... real life-savers.
thanks again for sharing. we never know how our experiences can help others.
-
-
Unsu...
Re: Self-preservation
Thu, December 9, 2004 - 5:20 AMeveryone has been through something. i havent been through that much..i am still here (hee hee)
i think of the old jewish lady i cared for that survived ww2. she saw the germans shoot her parents and entire family in front of her when she was just a little girl. and that still made her cry like a baby at 88. i have never had anything cut me like that. and i hope i never will.
i totally have to have something/someone to care about or i dont see a point.
funny you brought up the thing about pets. at that time was the first time that i didnt have a cat in my life.
as dumb as i t sounds when i was working at a job i hated and i didnt want to go to work...i would look at my fatty boy simon cat and could haul my ass out of bet for him. a cat! im wierd. -
-
Re: Self-preservation
Thu, December 9, 2004 - 7:38 AMPets make a HUGE difference :-). 35 years with cats (and the occasional dog) followed by a year and a half with a VERY foul tempered flying squirrel, and another cat is now part of the furniture. Cats are very much a stableizing influence :-).
I knew a jewish woman way back when who was very similar, don't remember her age. She told me a few things that she'd experienced, it was truly life changing. There was a story I read somewhere about a man in a concentration camp who discovered true freedom there, under torture, and wrote about it. He said that freedom comes from within, and once you accept your own freedom, no one can take it away, even when you are imprisoned and tortured. I can't remember WHERE I read his story, or his name, but remember the message. -
-
Re: Self-preservation
Thu, December 9, 2004 - 7:55 AMelie wiesel's book, Night, reminds me of your story, Chris.
you're post sent me into a laughing fit: a VERY foul tempered flying squirrel!!
cats are good for a laugh. they're very responsive and cuddly. i used to detest cats, until i owned one (saved from certain death in a logging forest). now i love them. yes, they can be independent, but they reward you with purrs and rubs and meows. i love dogs for sure for their loyalty and protectiveness and responsive tail-wagging, but there is much to love about playful, inquisitive, and responsive kittes, too.
-
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: Self-preservation
Thu, December 9, 2004 - 9:26 AMLol, SOME cats are strange. I can't go anywhere in my house without mine following (have to keep him out the darkroom these days, working with a rather toxic soup for some films, he howls outside the door). I think he's concinced he's a dog. He is one of the most DEPENDENT cats I've ever owned :-).
Yeah, Dancer was a handful. He was a Giant Formosan Flying Squirrel, best loved from a distance (I was bloodied many times when his mood changed while on my shoulder)...I sometimes think about getting another one, but not having to ask for cover fire when heading to the bathroom at night is a REALLY amazing luxury.
That book doesn't ring a bell, I'm thinking that I may be remembering a story that was related to me somewhere, I'll check out that book, though. It is probably well worth reading.
-
-
-
Re: Self-preservation
Thu, December 9, 2004 - 8:00 AMmy heart breaks for the victims of such horrible violence. it makes it all the more clear that we must awaken our empathy for other human beings. it is what keeps us all alive and conscious and living well.
we must also be kind to ourselves, giving the same compassion to ourselves. i once saw a woman, old and worn with years, and i saw the beauty in her wise expression. i felt compassion for her in her faded youth. then i realized that such kind and loving thoughts i rarely give to myself. we often reserve mercy and compassion for others without applying to our own experience. this is something i work on.
it's not weird that you love and get out of bed for your simon cat, violet. :) it shows your love by doing. that's a great kind of love.
-
-
-
-
-
-